Sunday, 14 April 2013

Discussion Post 2



In 1939 unemployment stood at 9.2 million; in 1929, it was 2.6 million. Why is FDR remembered by scholars and by the American public as a great, even the greatest President? (100 words, by Friday 19/4 5pm).

13 comments:

  1. FDR is remembered as one of the greatest Presidents ever known because he was responsible for the New Deal. The New Deal was considered a second American revolution as it, evidently, instituted a new form of government and reshaped the relationship between the Americans and the government for generations to come. The New Deal dealt with averting crises through setting up laws and organisations that would avoid a situation like the Great Depression again. It also had an ambitious program of social and economic reform which introduced the pension scheme for the first time and aided needy children and the unemployed.

    ReplyDelete
  2. FDR’s introduction of the New Deal was a large turning point in America’s economy which improved rapidly with the introduction of the legislation, before relapsing into recession. FDR can be remembered as one of the greatest Presidents as he launched the New Deal which dealt with producing relief and providing jobs for the unemployed in order to attempt to prevent recession. We are able to view this legislation as a contributing factor to FDR’s status as a great, or the greatest President of America.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Through a number of sweeping economic reforms under the New Deal, he is controversially considered as one of America's greatest presidents. The emergency banking act effectively shut down innate banks while those that were still productive received government support. This meant that citizens were once again able to invest in their banks confidently again during the Depression. He ended over-production from farmers allowing preservation of land, and established the Civilian Conservation Corps, which allowed environmental work for unemployed younger citizens. Despite these positives, FDR's policies generated very little wealth for the U.S economy and businesses continued to suffer.

    ReplyDelete
  5. FDR’s lasting popularity despite high unemployment shows the legacy of a president is not evaluated on his economic record alone. Scholars revere FDR for his enduring legacy in the performance of government; the New Deal redefined its social and economic roles for generations. A Democrat majority in both houses allowed him to pass legislation quickly, adding an air of efficiency to the popular reforms he was enacting. Combined with a good relationship with the press and his populist ‘fireside chats’ these reforms, however questionably efficient, endeared FDR to the majority of Americans. His legacy was further enhanced by the aura of being a wartime president, and the tragedy of dying in office.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Roosevelt’s New Deal permanently changed the federal governments relationship with the U.S. populace. This significant turning point in American government policy saw the federal government take far more responsibly for the economic welfare of the people than it had in any previous administration. When FDR took office America had just been through one of the bleakest years of the Great Depression, he acted swiftly to try and stabilize the economy and provide jobs and relief to those who were suffering. He oversaw the institution of a series of experimental projects and programs, known as the New Deal; that aimed to restore some measure of dignity and prosperity to many Americans. Despite controversy over how affective these policies were, it was these bold and decisive actions that allow FDR to be viewed as one of Americas greatest Presidents.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The legacy of FDR and his radical new deal program following the crash of the American economy in 1929 under the hoover administration secured his place as Americas greatest president. His radical new deal programs can be seen as a turning point in American economic history that saw job prosperity flourish and a new found faith in the Rooselvelt government amongst the American people. The new deal program saw a swift and radical new economic program that turned away from hoovers idea of a “boom and bust” economy that would repair itself and saw the American government take a real responsibility for the turnaround of the American economy following the depression. For these reasons, Roosevelt is seen as the greatest American president.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Franklin D. Roosevelt is remembered for being a great American President for two main reasons.

    Firstly, he introduced the New Deal; an economic program that had the federal government intervene in America’s economy to ensure prosperity and jobs for many Americans during the Great Depression.

    Secondly, he was the president that guided the United States through the Second World War after the attack on Pearl Harbour on December 7 1941. Industrial demand resulted in a sharp decrease in unemployment and America becoming an economic powerhouse by the end of Roosevelt’s presidency in 1945, with 50% of the world’s economic output being American. Furthermore, as a result of WWII America rose to become an economic powerhouse, which many Americans considered to be the US’s destiny.

    ReplyDelete
  9. FDR is remembered as one of the greatest presidents ever for a number of reasons. Firstly, his confidence in implementing the economic reforms of the New Deal provided immediate aid to the US people emerging from the Great Depression, and set a precedent that continues to shape how the U.S. is run today (pension scheme, unemployment benefits etc.).

    Whilst he failed to acknowledge racial inequality, FDR's wife Eleanor Roosevelt boosted his popularity, as did his “fireside chats” which spoke directly to the American people. His role leading up to World War II also set the U.S. up as an emerging global superpower – a position it still holds today.

    FDR was therefore instrumental in his political and economic reforms but also in his ability to listen to and help the people of America - a role that has labeled him as one of American’s greatest President.

    ReplyDelete
  10. FDR’s ascension to the title of “most popular president” can be attributed mainly to his New Deal legislation, an economic plan designed to pull the United States from its dire financial situation. The New Deal aimed at creating jobs and giving aid to the millions of people who found themselves jobless after the crash of 1929. The previous Hoover government’s strategy of “waiting it out” and their notion of Boom and Bust plunged the once thriving economy of the US into further turmoil, so FDR’s New Deal would have been regarded very highly among the American public, thus propelling his popularity and earning him the title of Most Popular President.

    ReplyDelete
  11. FDR is considered one of the greatest US Presidents (along with George Washington and Abraham Lincoln) by both scholars and the public. This is largely for the same reasons.

    The slew of New Deal programs introduced in 1933 provided a great boost to the US economy, and despite the eventual recession in 1937 scholars consider him to have achieved good results througout his tenure. A large number of the public felt FDR went above and beyond for them in a time where economic interference by the Govt. was uncommon, and were grateful for the jobs created.

    Leading the US to victory during World War II thus securing their freedom and position as the foremost economic power in the world also endeared FDR to scholars and his constituency.

    ReplyDelete
  12. First of all I did this response on my iphone and I only just checked on my laptop and it didn't load! So hopefully you won't dismiss this late (but not intended late) response

    FDR was remembered as a great, and to many the greatest, American president because of the introduction of the New Deal and more importantly the long-term effect these policies had influenced/impacted on the following decades. The first hundred days of the New Deal, immediately initiated after his 1933 Presidential election, helped secure national banks, implement jobs and shift the social environment of such dramatic times. He illustrated, especially in a time where many were convinced economic depressions were in a sense natural patterned, that enough perseverance could conquer anything.

    ReplyDelete
  13. FDR was largely remembered as being a president of legacy due to his enactment of the New Deal. The long-term liberal economic policies institutionalised by Roosevelt's policies included integral initiatives such as the Public Works Administration, Civilian Conservation Corps and Public Works Administration. The main targets of the New Deal and by extension his administration's goals were to create jobs, regulate the national banking system and instill a sense of confidence and morale within the people and their government. In spite of criticisms that they've faced, Roosevelt's policies rejuvenated America and pulled it out of the Depression

    ReplyDelete